What is an Inherency argument?
Inherency. Inherency is a stock issue in policy debate that refers to a barrier that keeps a harm from being solved in the status quo.
What are the types of Inherency?
Three common types of inherency are:
- Structural inherency: Laws or other barriers to the implementation of the plan or causes of harms.
- Attitudinal inherency: Beliefs or attitudes which prevent the implementation of the plan or causing harms.
What are the five stock issues?
Brief introduction to the stock issues Basically, the stock issues are a list of concepts that help answer the question “Is this a good decision (or policy, law, etc.)? ” With that note, my list is as follows: topicality, inherency, significance, solvency, disadvantages, alternatives.
What is a counterplan in debate?
While some conceptions of debate theory require the negative position in a debate to defend the status quo against an affirmative position or plan, a counterplan allows the negative to defend a separate plan or an advocacy. It also allows the affirmative to run disadvantages against the negative.
What are the four stock issues?
The standard “stock issues” presented as planks are Topicality, Inherency, Harms, and Solvency. Significance can be interwoven into any of those. Topicality is usually a simple matter to be argued later if the Negative brings up the issue.
What are the 5 stock issues for policy debate?
Stock Issues: Issues common to most decision-making situations. In policy debate, they refer to topicality, significance, inherency, and solvency.
What is an example of topicality?
Meaning of topicality in English. the quality of being of interest at the present time, or of relating to things that are happening at present: This movie suddenly has more topicality than its makers intended. Unsurprisingly, given the raging topicality of the subject, there were no preview copies of the book available …
How do you run a topicality argument?
They are: definition, standards, violation, and voting issues. In order to win a topicality argument, a negative needs to isolate one word or term in the resolution that the affirmative has not upheld in their interpretation of the resolution. Then, the negative needs to define that term.
What is a non unique argument?
The “non-unique” argument says that the impact will happen in the status quo with or without the passage of the plan or that it is happening in the status quo. The links and impacts (and thus the entire disadvantage) become largely irrelevant since the status quo is no different from the plan.
What is a conditional counterplan?
A conditional counterplan status means that negative accepts little or no limitation on its ability to advocate counterplans.
Why is policy called CX?
It is also referred to as cross-examination debate (sometimes shortened to Cross-X, CX, Cross-ex, or C-X) because of the 3-minute questioning period following each constructive speech.
What are the main stock issues for policy speeches?
In debate, these are how the affirmative meets the burden of proof; together, they are topicality, inherency, significance of harms, and solvency.
What is topicality in research?
An important document feature is topicality, which can be defined as the level of the document’s relevance to the topic of the citing document (Wang & Soergel, 1998). In general, hot topics have a higher topicality for citing authors, and in turn attract more attention and citations from the scientific community.
Why is topicality important in debate?
Topicality (T) is an argument debating whether or not the affirmative’s plan follows the resolution. The negative team can use this argument to prove that the affirmative’s plan promotes definitions of words in the resolution are incorrect or not good enough.
What is inherency in debate?
All in all, inherency is something debaters should understand and be able to defend, if necessary, and use to attack the aff on the very rare occasion that it’s the best available argument for winning the round. Certain types of debate find more use for it than others. This is a great overview of inherency.
What is the meaning of inherence?
Definition of inherency 1 : inherence 2 : an inherent character or attribute culture classifications with purely taxonomic inherencies — W. W. Taylor
How do you rely on the doctrine of inherency?
Procedurally, to rely on the doctrine of inherency, one must provide a basis in fact and/or technical reasoning supporting a determination that an allegedly inherent characteristic necessarily would be present if the teachings of the prior art were followed, even if the inherent feature would not have been recognized.
What is the difference between a non-unique and no inherency argument?
In other words, a “no inherency” is to the top of case what “non-unique” is to an advantage or disadvantage. It uses the same logic to attack the argument with the added bonus that, since inherency is a stock issue, winning a no inherency argument usually means winning the round.